Liability Subject of Oil Pollution Damage in Both-to-Blame Vessel Collision
Background
In 2011, M/V “Hamburg Bridge” collided with M/V “Oriental Sunrise” in the channel of Qingdao Port, which caused M/V “Oriental Sunrise” sunk and oil spilled while M/V “Hamburg Bridge” only suffered slight hull damages without oil spill.
Thereafter, the local MSA and fish farmers claimed for oil-cleaning expenses and aquaculture losses arising from oil pollution against the owners of the above two vessels respectively.
Qingdao Maritime Court adjudged the collision liability as 70:30 in favor of M/V “Hamburg Bridge”.
Comments
Although the above oil pollution claims are settled amicably, some legal issues are worth discussed, especially the liability subject of oil pollution damage in both-to-blame collision.
Currently, there are three controversial opinions as to the liability subject of oil pollution damage arising from both-to-blame collision.
The first opinion holds that the oil pollution damage arising from ship collision shall be regarded as third parties’ property losses in accordance with Article 169 of the Maritime Code of PRC, based on which the colliding vessels shall undertake liability in proportion. Guangdong High People’s Court upheld such opinion in the collision case between M/T “Min Ran Gong 2” and M/T “Dong Hai 209” in 2000.
The second opinion is that pursuant to the General Principles of the Civil Law of PRC and the Tort Law of PRC, both of the colliding vessels commit the t tort and shall assume the t liability. Guangzhou Maritime Court supported such opinion in the collision case between M/V “Vacherna Breeze” and M/V “Chao He” in 1988.
The last opinion takes the view that on grounds of the basic principle of “the oil-spill vessel shall be liable for the damage” as set out in international conventions for oil pollution damage, it is the oil-spill vessel/tanker other than the non-oil-spill one that shall be liable for oil pollution damages. Guangzhou Maritime Court was of such opinion in the collision case between M/T “Min Ran Gong 2” and M/T “Dong Hai 209” in 1999.